What should I do? My mechanic didn’t fix my car and now it is broken. What are my rights?

I am in need of some help.
I have a 1997 Z28 Camaro with lt1 6sp. I had a hole in the wall shop repair it. The guy charged me 220 for the clutch and 600 total cost. It wouldnt go into 1st gear very smooth. so 2 days later i took it back to him to have it adjusted/fixed. He said that he had adjusted it. I had the motor replaced tow months later & my new mechanic who built and installed my motor said it was bad.my new mechanic said that my old mechanic had never drained the slave cylinder & in 97 the slave cylinder was not adjustable on my car(So how did he adjust my clutch with out taking out the trans?). The man who built my motor said it wouldn’t last long before it broke. sure enough 75 miles later it goes out.

The guy is an old Mexican man who pays some Mexican who speaks almost no English (Illegal?) to work on the cars. I am going to go to his shop tomorrow. I dont know how to approach it & what to say to him to get him to replace it with no charge and fix it. The clutch has less than 1000 miles on it and was done 9/9/09 then the motor was blown a month later (not from hard driving) and parked for two months until 4 days ago. So the clutch should still be under warranty with who ever he bought it friom. I know he used a crappy clutch that wouldnt be able to hold that kind of performance for a long time but i need a new one that’ll last me until I get another job and can afford it.

What should I do? How should I approach it. If he is unwilling what can I do to scare him into replacing it. He is not registered on the BBB. And even I know that they cant do anything because they are just a company (Franchise) and not a GOV regulated company. All I want him to do is to put a new clutch in it and install it for me. I would prefer not to make a big deal and take him to court but would like to know what I can do if it needs to come to that. Or at least how it works so I can use the leverage to get him to do it. I dont want the new motor to ruin my chances of getting this issue resolved. The mechanic who installed it has been building Corvette motors for over 15 years and knows his stuff. Would recommend him to anyone. But I need to have this issue fixed asap.

I really appreciate any help or advice that you can give me. Thank you very much.

Well this is buyer be ware, even in court you don’t stand a chance. First off if you had a guy who can build a motor for you why not get him to do the clutch? Also so you know clutches have nothing to do with your engine braking down. The clutch is the safety between your motor and your transmission, it will fail before your engine or transmission. The only thing that can damage an engine beyond repair is connecting rod failure and that has nothing to do with the clutch, as a matter of fact even if the clutch was in direct contact at all times unless you release the clutch your vehicle would be going nowhere. Just so you also know a Corvette engine is idiot proof GM did not want to risk it here with their pride an joy, anyone with a manual can fix a corvette engine, also if you look into it a Corvette engine has about 10 less components than your conventional V8 engine, making it highly tunable. I mean for 600 bucks you could of gotten just about any reputable shop to do it why didn’t you..That is what they will tell you in court…

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

5 Responses to “What should I do? My mechanic didn’t fix my car and now it is broken. What are my rights?”

  1. wiseornotyoudecide says:

    Well this is buyer be ware, even in court you don’t stand a chance. First off if you had a guy who can build a motor for you why not get him to do the clutch? Also so you know clutches have nothing to do with your engine braking down. The clutch is the safety between your motor and your transmission, it will fail before your engine or transmission. The only thing that can damage an engine beyond repair is connecting rod failure and that has nothing to do with the clutch, as a matter of fact even if the clutch was in direct contact at all times unless you release the clutch your vehicle would be going nowhere. Just so you also know a Corvette engine is idiot proof GM did not want to risk it here with their pride an joy, anyone with a manual can fix a corvette engine, also if you look into it a Corvette engine has about 10 less components than your conventional V8 engine, making it highly tunable. I mean for 600 bucks you could of gotten just about any reputable shop to do it why didn’t you..That is what they will tell you in court…
    References :

  2. ahpolkguy says:

    Sorry, you have to proof other than your new mechanic, which I would not fully trust either. Did he show you the clutch to why it’ll not last another 75 miles. Was there something wrong with the clutch before you engine blown?

    The old guy may have just bleed the slave cylinder to fix the shifting problem. It was fixed right? Building Corvette means nothing to me, there’s not special about building LS1 motors. If he has two large Snap-on tool cases, fill with snap-on tools then he can say something.
    References :

  3. N says:

    Rights ? LOL

    You have the right to sue the guy or not if you cant work out a suitable arrangement.

    Can you PROVE the mechanic did something wrong ? What does your receipt say ?

    Suppose that the mechanic doesn’t show up and you win the suit. Guess what ? Its up to YOU to try and collect.
    References :

  4. dale b says:

    You aren’t going to get any satisfaction from this guy. If I were you, I’d take it to the guy who did the motor, and have him do the clutch. The other guy will just screw it up again. Good luck.
    References :
    30+ years in the car biz.

  5. euroman71 says:

    That’s why you should never go to a hole in the wall type of repair shop. Always make sure that mechanics are certified and that the workers doing the work are legitimate. You can’t really prove anything at this point and even if you go to court, do you really want to spend time and money on the lost cause? It’s unfortunate situation and years ago I took my car to the local shop only to find out that the owner was arrested and jailed. My car along with few others was locked up inside the shop by police for 2 months for some sort of evidence. When I finally got it, it wasn’t fixed and some parts were missing from it as well.
    References :

Leave a Reply